Property damage

Your Car After a Texas Crash: Repairs, Rentals and Diminished Value

Even when nobody is hurt, the property damage claim has more to it than a repair bill.

Updated November 17, 2026 · General information, not legal advice

Damaged SUV in an auto body repair shop

Repair or total loss

The at-fault driver's insurer owes the reasonable cost to repair your car — or, if repairs would cost more than the car is worth, its fair market value right before the crash. You can choose your own repair shop. On a total loss, compare the insurer's valuation to real listings for the same year, make, model, trim and mileage in the Amarillo market; valuations are negotiable.

Rental car and loss of use

You're entitled to be compensated for the loss of use of your car for a reasonable time while it's repaired or replaced — typically shown by a comparable rental. The Texas Supreme Court has held that loss-of-use damages are available even when the vehicle is a total loss. If you have rental coverage on your own policy, you can use it while the other insurer accepts fault.

Diminished value

A car that has been in a significant crash is often worth less after repairs than an identical car that never was — a buyer will see the history. That difference is diminished value.

  • Against the at-fault driver's insurer (a third-party claim), diminished value can be recovered in Texas as part of your property damage.
  • Against your own insurer under a standard Texas auto policy, the Texas Supreme Court has held diminished value is not covered — so if you use your collision coverage, you'd pursue diminished value from the at-fault driver's side.

Support a diminished value claim with an independent appraisal and the repair records. It matters most on newer and higher-value vehicles.

Personal property

Items damaged in the crash — a phone, a laptop, a car seat — are part of the claim. Child car seats are generally replaced after a moderate or severe crash.

Don't sign away the injury claim

Settling the property damage claim shouldn't release your injury claim. Read anything you're asked to sign; a property-damage release should say it covers property only.

Sources

Statutes are linked to the official Texas Legislature site. Laws change; this page reflects them as of the date above.

Hurt in a crash in Amarillo?

Talk it through with a local car accident lawyer before you talk to the insurance company. The review is free.

Call now