Insurance

Car Accident Claim Denied or Lowballed in Texas? What to Do

A denial or a lowball offer isn't the end of a claim. It's often the insurer's opening position.

Updated November 17, 2026 · General information, not legal advice

Insurance claim paperwork and medical bills

Why claims get denied or undervalued

  • Fault is disputed — their driver blames you, and there's no report or witness to settle it.
  • Gaps in treatment or treatment that started late.
  • Pre-existing conditions they say explain your symptoms.
  • Low property damage, used to argue you couldn't have been hurt.
  • Coverage problems — a lapsed policy, an excluded driver, or a vehicle used for business.

Who you're dealing with

When you claim against the at-fault driver's insurer, that company's duties run to its own policyholder, not to you. In Texas you generally can't sue the other driver's insurance company directly; you pursue the driver, and their insurer defends and pays within its limits. That's why the real leverage in a stalled claim is a lawsuit against the driver.

Claims against your own insurer are different

When the claim is under your own policy — PIP, UM/UIM or collision — your insurer owes you contractual duties, and Texas's prompt-payment law sets deadlines for acknowledging, investigating and paying claims, with penalties for late payment. You can file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance.

What to do

  1. Ask for the reason in writing.
  2. Fill the gaps: get the crash report, witness statements, video, photos and complete medical records.
  3. Don't give a new recorded statement to the other insurer.
  4. Watch the calendar: negotiations don't pause the two-year filing deadline.
  5. Get a free case review. An attorney can send a formal demand, and if needed file suit, which is often when a fair offer arrives.

Sources

Statutes are linked to the official Texas Legislature site. Laws change; this page reflects them as of the date above.

Hurt in a crash in Amarillo?

Talk it through with a local car accident lawyer before you talk to the insurance company. The review is free.

Call now